November 7, 2026
The English on Crusade 5 - Kings: Manipulation or Unfulfilled Desire?

William Rufus to Henry II

In Pilgrims and Strangers I needed to send an English character on crusade, but which crusade? This led to extensive (probably excessive) research on the English participation during the crusading period up to 1230. In part five of a series of blogs I will examine the relationship between the reigning king and the crusading movement, starting with William Rufus and ending with Henry II.

Kings were secular men and thus shared the same interests as their barons but at a higher level and in a wider sense. Like their barons, their interests were focused on their rights of property and their rights of jurisdiction. Their patrimony incorporated their kingdom, duchies and other continental possessions over which they governed with their vassals, the great magnates, doing homage for the lands they held of the king. Kings swore an oath at their coronation to preserve the peace of their people, to maintain order and to ensure justice. Kings had a duty, embodied in a sanctified promise, to defend their secular interests above all else.

William Rufus

Initially, kings of England showed scant interest in crusading - their secular affairs were too pressing for them to abandon. William Rufus had put down an English rebellion in the same year Urban II called for the First Crusade. Moreover, his brother offered him the opportunity of 'temporarily' holding Normandy, thus uniting the patrimony divided on their father's death. Robert Curthose left his duchy 'wretchedly tormented by the feuds of her sons' as a form of voluntary exile from his secular interests because he feared 'still worse to come since almost everyone had abandoned him' (Orderic Vitalis). His agreement with his brother secured his patrimony at a time when William Rufus could have annexed the patrimony by force. Because Robert took the cross, William stayed at home. Within months of their agreement, William Rufus raised the huge sum of 10,000 marks as payment; he had invested in the duchy of Normandy, the crusade held no interest for him.

Henry I

Having newly acquired his crown, Henry I was unable to respond to the wave of enthusiasm which swept the West in 1100. Ambitious to rule Normandy as well as his kingdom, Henry spent six years protecting his crown from his elder brother's claim and seeking to hold the duchy. In the years following Robert's capture in 1106, Henry enforced his authority over Normandy and became embroiled in incessant conflicts on the continent. After the death of his only legitimate son in 1120, he constantly sought to solve the problem of his succession. Thus, during his reign, there was no period of time in which Henry could have left for the Holy Land. The French king, neighbouring Counts and his own Norman vassals would probably have taken advantage of his absence to Henry's detriment.

Stephen

Stephen's hold of his crown was precarious throughout most of his reign. In 1146 when the Second Crusade was promulgated, Empress Maud was still in England while Geoffrey of Anjou had an uncontested hold over Normandy. Even the relatively quieter years between 1148 and 1153 were not totally peaceful. Stephen himself acknowledged that he had never fully controlled England - the Treaty of Winchester (November 1153) required 'the earls and barons of the duke [Henry of Anjou] who were never my men' to pay Stephen homage. Stephen's authority was continually threatened with the danger of the barons' shifting loyalties ever-present. To depart on crusade would have left his throne empty for those who vied to sit there themselves.

Henry II

Crusading privileges invoked by Pope Eugenius III (1146) protected a prospective crusader's property and person from disseisin and judgement. Henry II (and his son, John) appear to use the crusading vow as a means of manipulating secular politics for their own ends. For over twenty years, Henry II promised to take the cross before he actually did so. Henry claimed he wished to take the cross once he was reconciled with Becket and so gained the support of Louis VII and the Archbishop of Tyre on two separate occasions. As a result, Becket attempted to compromise briefly and settlements were reached over territorial gains with Louis. Part of Henry's penance for the murder of Becket, which brought peace between himself and the Church, was a promise to take the cross. Many came to view Henry's sincerity with scepticism, including Louis VII, who would not believe his promises until 'he saw his shoulder marked with the sign of the cross.' However, Louis was repeatedly swayed by such pledges of intent and 'was the more inclined ... to enter an agreement with Henry' (The Letters of John of Salisbury). Henry used the crusading oath as a manipulative tool in the governing of his dominions; that he was successful, demonstrates the power of the vow.

Absence on crusade was temporary; no king risked losing all he possessed. Throughout his reign, Henry's dominant policy, from which he never deviated, was the rule of his widely flung domains. His earlier promises to crusade were made on the condition that 'I am allowed to set my house in order and make disposition for my children' (The Letters of John of Salisbury). This Henry was never able to do - peace within the lands he ruled and between his warring sons was never accomplished. From 1166 to 1171 he was involved in skirmishes with Louis VII as he reaffirmed his borders. The 1173-4 rebellion and the period afterwards, when Henry reasserted his control over his lands and his sons, was not the time for Henry to leave for the Holy Land. This was acknowledged by the Pope himself around 1175 when he allowed Henry to commute part of his penance for Becket's murder - his vow to take the cross. Henry's four sons also caused much disharmony as they fought with each other or joined forces against their father, while Henry attempted to resolver the problem of his succession.

Henry was not alone in believing that his priorities were the governance of his dominions. In 1185, a council of earls, barons, bishops and abbots advised him not to heed the Patriarch of Jerusalem's appeal to leave for the Holy Land because the king 'should govern the kingdom with due care and protect it from foreigners and from external enemies' rather than 'in his own person seek the preservation of the easterners' (Ralph of Diceto).

When Henry finally took the cross in January 1188 with Philip II, it appears he had every intention of fulfilling the vow. His continental and English barons were summoned to Le Mans and Geddington, respectively, to hear and approve the taxation and ordinances agreed by the two kings. Letters were sent to the rulers of Germany, Hungary and Constantinople requesting safe passage and food supplies. Henry encouraged enthusiasm and provided for a campaign of recruitment in Wales. When Philip II invaded Aquitainian Berry in response to Richard's actions, Henry sent a powerful delegation to negotiate 'any kind of arrangement for the restoration of peace' (Gervase of Canterbury).

Richard was blamed by many contemporaries for Henry's delayed departure. He too sought to confirm his secular position as Henry's heir – something Henry had refused to do since his eldest son’s death in 1183. If Henry had not died in July 1189, it is possible the third major crusading venture to the East would never have occurred. Henry stubbornly refused to acknowledge Richard as his heir while Richard's reaction was to invade Henry's lands with the encouragement and active support of Philip II. In the face of such unwillingness to compromise, neither Richard nor Henry could afford to leave their secular interests so vulnerable to attack.

Therefore, Henry's eastern commitments to aid his family, the rulers of the Kingdom of Jerusalem, were never subordinate to his rule over his western domains. Prior to 1188 Henry's actions were motivated by the protection of his own interest. His numerous promises to take the cross were used to ring concessions and cooperation from others. Plans to depart on crusade were ultimately thwarted by threats to his lands and his authority. Henry is guilty of manipulating the crusading vow. However, evidence suggests his commitment to crusade, when finally made, was genuine and cheated by death.

In part six, I will look at Richard I and John.